Pies n Thighs

All 156 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Three Best places to get chicken fried steak ?5 pts
“it's not really a good example of cfs. The breading isn't crisp enough and falls off the meat easily.”
H3
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“I had a terrible meal there. Service was chaotic and disinterested and my kid got a massive splinter from their unvarnished, fucked up table and they did nothing about it.”
H3
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“The chicken was cooked very well but totally flavorless and the Mac and cheese was pretty disappointing.”
H3
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“I thought it was good, a novelty ro get fried chicken that is made fresh and not fast food.”
H3
postI kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed285 pts
“I thought this restaurant would be much better so many ppl review this high saying how good it is and nope.”
H2
in:American cuisine28 pts
“I love pies n thighs. Great biscuits, pie, and the best cinnamon roll I’ve had.”
H2
postWilliamsburg Icon Pies 'n' Thighs Opens Spiffy New Spot in Park Slope17 pts
“Basically, like the original, the new Pies 'n' Thighs not only serves a lot of great food that even the pickiest eaters in your family/friend group can get with, it's also a very useful restaurant to have close by at all times of day and night.”
H2
in:Small Food Tour NYC, need some help9 pts
“Pies and thighs: fried chicken”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed7 pts
“The new location in downtown Brooklyn is so bad. The chicken biscuit is half the size as it was at the Williamsburg location.”
H2
in:Best dessert in Williamsburg?6 pts
“Pies and Thighs' pecan pie (and well, their entire menu) is so good I have trouble trying anything else in the area.”
H2
in:Looking for a great dessert spot for a date night6 pts
replying to u/Raginghangers: Petee's pies has the best pies. I did a pretty extensive taste-test for my wedding and they were the winner.
“Pie's and Thighs Key Lime is really good”
H2
in:Are there any places in SoHo up to Midtown that serve EXCELLENT sausage gravy (and biscuits, but most important is the gravy)6 pts
“Pies and thighs biscuit is good”
H2
in:Has anyone from SF found an equivalent to “The Bird” chicken sandwich in NYC?6 pts
“Pies n thighs in Williamsburg has an amazing chicken biscuit sandwich. Mmmmmm. I wish I had one at the moment.”
H2
in:Can we talk pies? 5 pts
“Banana cream pie from Pies n Thighs in Williamsburg”
H2
in:Where do you order in from in the city when you’re sad or stressed and need either comfort food or food that feels good when your appetite is low?5 pts
“Biscuits and Gravy from Pies and Thighs also deserves a recommendation.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed5 pts
replying to u/FajitaTits: You went to Pies n Thighs and didn’t get either of the things in its namesake?
“Their fried chicken and gravy is awesome.”
H2
in:Clinton Baking Company has the worst biscuits I've ever had.3 pts
replying to u/laughingwalls: Yeah, so a couple next to me ordered the Eggs Benedict and Pancakes, they actually looked good. I grew up in the south, so I couldn't resist not ordering the biscuit in the off chance it was decent. I didn't have high expectations, but it was terrible. I kept looking at their pancakes, and was like this place probably deserves a second chance.
“Closest place I’ve come to a real biscuit is pies and thighs.”
H2
in:Favorite fried Chicken restaurant?3 pts
replying to u/pink3rbellx: For Korean fried chicken, Chicken Insider on UES. For southern fried chicken, it’s hard to find any that compares to the south in NYC but Amy Ruth’s is good. I prob will get downvoted but also a fan of Pies N Thighs in Brooklyn.
“Pies and thighs and commodore are the best I've had in the city I think.”
H2
in:What is the best chicken you’ve had in NYC?3 pts
“The chicken biscuit at pies n thighs in Williamsburg is pretty tasty”
H2
in:Fried Chicken3 pts
“you will be recommended things like pies and thighs but it’s greasy and gross.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed3 pts
“the biscuits with honey butter were fantastic. So was the sausage gravy.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed3 pts
“That is the momst burn biscuit I've seen in a while.”
H2
in:What are peoples favorite places in Brooklyn for fried chicken?2 pts
replying to u/halermine: Pies and Thighs will hook you up
“Seriously the best, and the Apple pie!”
H2
in:Best Breakfast in Williamsburg2 pts
“chicken and waffles at pies n thighs”
H2
in:Fried Chicken2 pts
“Pies n thighs is great and expensive”
H2
in:Going to spend 2+ weeks in NY in August. Recs?2 pts
“I’m from the south and there’s basically only one place in the city I’ve been that makes on the bone fried chicken as good as I’ve had it in the south or even as good as popeyes and that place is pies n thighs in williamsburg”
H2
in:What are some of the worst meals you've had recently?2 pts
“the banana cream pie at Pies and Thighs was inedible.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
replying to u/FajitaTits: You went to Pies n Thighs and didn’t get either of the things in its namesake?
“I ordered a banana cream pie and was really disappointed”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
replying to u/Shadowtirs: Hmmm, this is sad to hear. I haven't been there in a while, so now I want to see if this is hyperbole or I agree with you.
“It's still great, they just ordered poorly. Fried chicken, pies, biscuits, all great.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“Everything there is just incredibly dry”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“They sell day old donuts at their Flatbush Avenue location - stale, talking bout $5 a donut - lazy and bad”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
replying to u/Hour_Professional479: They sell day old donuts at their Flatbush Avenue location - stale, talking bout $5 a donut - lazy and bad
“I had a fresh one there that was bussin’ recently”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“I've been there twice and was vaguely disappointed both times. Their fried chicken is fine. Agree that grits were good.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“the worst piece of chicken I’ve ever paid for. Sincerely atrocious”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“I found the chicken to be okay just missing one thing, flavor”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“Mac and cheese there was disappointing”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“Their pies and thighs are good, not great but good, especially for NYC.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“I love that place. Their fried chicken is awesome and the pecan pie is amazing. The biscuit and gravy is awesome too.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed2 pts
“I agreed with OP until I noticed he ordered catfish and not chicken.”
H2
in:Favorite fried Chicken restaurant?1 pts
replying to u/phoenixmatrix: Pies and Thighs is ridiculously good. Make sure to get a pecan pie at the end too.
“But agreed - perfect fried chicken!”
H2
in:Can we talk pies? 1 pts
“I’ve gotten pies from Pies N Thighs before and those went over well.”
H2
in:Can we talk pies? 1 pts
“I love the one from pies n thighs”
H2
in:biscuits and gravy1 pts
replying to u/pallascatparty: Pies n Thighs in Brooklyn
“That one was alright, the gravy I had was really thin, almost watery.”
H2
in:pickle appetizer1 pts
“Deep fried pickle chips. Ranch dipping sauce. Amazing.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
replying to u/ciregno: Yeah I'm not taking Pies n Thighs slander. Their fried chicken and gravy is awesome.
“the waffles with the cinnamon sauce was so freaking good. I did not appreicate the butter drenched biscuit..way too much butter.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
replying to u/FajitaTits: You went to Pies n Thighs and didn’t get either of the things in its namesake?
“I found my meals just “fine.” The chicken was crisp but under seasoned.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“now it's good chicken at astronomical prices.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“All the sweets I've had have been good. Key lime pie, apple crumble, and I had a really delicious donut from there the other day (new location on Flatbush). Food is just alright though, and they seem to have eliminated the cheapest beer/wine options they had when they first opened.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“I thought it was solid at the price point.”
H2
in:I kept hearing about “Pies n Thighs” finally to be disappointed1 pts
“Pies are actually the worst thing on their menu”
H2