“the new Wegmans rivals any grocery store in manhattan. I was blown away with their meat and fish department. Cuts and fish I had never seen before, service was incredible, everything so fresh.”
H3
All 170 rated mentions, most helpful first
“the new Wegmans rivals any grocery store in manhattan. I was blown away with their meat and fish department. Cuts and fish I had never seen before, service was incredible, everything so fresh.”
H3
“They do the fresh blue fin tuna cutting every weekend and it's extremely fresh. You can buy the sushi rice right there as well as the tuna and they'll make the nigiri for you, for much cheaper than any restaurant for that otoro fatty tuna quality level.”
H3
“Wegmans grocery store in the Navy Yard has the best in-house bakery I’ve ever seen. Several types of sourdough, pumpernickel, Challah, multigrain, you name it. Certainly comparable to a high-end boulangerie”
H3
“the new Wegmans in the EV blows it out of the water. I was there last week and there is a separate fish counter for “regular” Wegmans, then a separate one with at least 15-20 options flown in from Japan”
H3
“Incredible huge meatballs, placed into an equally big Italian bread.”
H3
“yeah, these cookies are amazing. I got an ultimate chocolate chip and double chocolate chip cookie to sample after buying them and immediately went back to buy boxes of both flavors to eat throughout the week.”
H2
“their sandwiches are on par with any decent deli.”
H2
“Including them for the sole reason that they have premade beefs-on-weck for purchase and they're not half-bad. The roll is what it's supposed to be, and the sandwich is big enough to make two meals from”
H2
“Wegman’s. I buy tuna and salmon there every week.”
H2
“**Wegman's** - actually has a fairly decent selection of nice meats and cheeses, though not as extensive as some of these other places”
H2
“It was all super fresh and looked amazing. Everything I've had there has been excellent.”
H2
“i vouch for Astor Pl Wegmans sashimi selection in the lower floor. Pricey but IMO the best for sushi night at home.”
H2
“Wegmans has the best tuna I've ever had”
H2
“Better than any bakery I stg”
H2
“Wegmans, which you can get the extra fatty tuna, it's $99/lb but you will understand when people say tuna is "buttery" after the extra fatty tuna experience.”
H2
“Wegman's does a really nice job with catering at a reasonable price.”
H2
“Wegmans for double chocolate chip.”
H2
“Wegman’s Ultimate Chocolate Chip cookie. Seriously, google photos of it. The Ultimate one specifically. The kind from their fresh cookies bar.”
H2
“It’s fine. Good food even, but definitely overpriced.”
H2
“They honestly have the best yellowtail sashimi too. Comparable to decent omakases.”
H2
“I got an amazingly good rosemary rotisserie chicken from Wegmans in Manhattan yesterday, $9.99.”
H2
“Wegman's has a coconut macaroon cookie that is out of this world.”
H2
“Wegmans. Salmon/tuna wrapped in seaweed with furikake, kewpie and wasabi. Could eat that shit every day.”
H2
“Wegmans with the whipped cream frosting.”
H2
“Wegmans makes excellent sheet cakes! I like the whipped cream frosting.”
H2
“I just had the Wegman's chicken the other day and it's fantastic.”
H2
“Listen to me right now, wegmans sheet cake.”
H2
“Wegman's cake is next level”
H2
“Wegman’s has amazing chocolate chip cookies”
H2
“it was the best cookie I’d ever eaten. Next time I bought them they were a little stale. But if you get them fresh, amazing.”
H2
“Everyone raved about how it tasted and there were a bunch of classic flavors available. They wrote a message on the spot too. 10/10 would buy again”
H2
“Wegmans has them beat on fresh fish from Japan.”
H2
“Just avoid their frozen Uni, its terrible.”
H2
“Wegmans is absolutely amazing and they'll let you try whatever before you buy, at least at the one at Astor Place.”
H2
“Honestly, the regular chocolate cake at Wegmans is really good - better than some fancy cakes I have had.”
H2
“Loved the space! I’ve read on this sub last week someone said that they think it’s not big enough/not enough variety, and I disagree.”
H2
“Wegmans in Astor place has a good wing bar”
H2
“The thing about Wegmans that stands out is their bread. The everything sub roll slaps so hard, and the consistency is amazing. Add sub oil to nearly any sub and it's a golden experience.”
H2
“My personal favorites are Wegmans (Astor Place) and Eataly (Flatiron) for rotisserie chicken.”
H2
“Came here to say this! If thin is what you want its hard to beat these!”
H2
“Wegmans chocolate chip cookie”
H2
“Get it with whipped cream and fruit inside. So good. They deliver too and you can do half chocolate half yellow. It's better than any wedding cake I've had.”
H2
“omg i adore the wegmans one too!”
H2
“Wegmans! Better than Whole Foods.”
H2
“I think Wegman’s is a good option at that price point:”
H2
“Not fancy at all but is swear the Wegmans chocolate cake is amazing!”
H2
“I do love Wegmans suns though.”
H2
“the Astor place location is very amped up and high end compared to any of the wegmans I have been to in other parts of the state lol. I don’t recall seeing Hokkaido sea scallops and a dry aged beef station in Buffalo haha.”
H2
“Wegmans!!! Danny’s mix and picante. If you know you know”
H2
“Wegmans uses the same shitty sushi robots that places like Sushiro/Hamasushi uses.”
H2