“9 bucks for 2 tiny little scoops. I mean I know it's NYC and everything but this was ridiculous. Ice Cream was good quality but not fantastic.”
H3
All 207 rated mentions, most helpful first
“9 bucks for 2 tiny little scoops. I mean I know it's NYC and everything but this was ridiculous. Ice Cream was good quality but not fantastic.”
H3
“Very sad, I loved their various types of vanillas, if they can differentiate between that many of such a basic flavor, you know they know what they're doing.”
H3
“All about Morgenstern's! Any guy who starts off his ice cream philosophy with reduced sugar and increased temperate so you can taste the difference between 5 different vanillas is the kind of food nerd I AM ABOUT!!”
H3
“The other 5 flavors are among the best ice creams ive ever had. Raw Milk especially is maybe my favorite flavor, period.”
H3
“the peaches and cream is great, the salted caramel pretzel is just a bit too salty.”
H2
“Durian Banana Ice Cream at Morgenstern's is an outlier for western palates, but I love it.”
H2
“I feel like the flavors can be hit or miss - some are awesome and some are just terrible (grainy texture, really unexpected flavor, etc.)”
H2
“It was really good! Like Laura Dern eating in the Jurassic Park cafeteria really good.”
H2
“the raspberry black sesame is my favorite, probably.”
H2
“they update their menu frequently and still have interesting ones in their current lineup - cheddar cheese Ritz bits, Hennessy honeycomb, matcha banana bread, strawberry pandan.”
H2
“False, it’s my favorite ice cream place in the city. Not an every day scoop by any means given the prices, though. Their Vietnamese coffee ice cream is maybe the best I’ve ever had”
H2
“I LOVE their special ones. My fave is the Vietnamese coffee.”
H2
“It depends on the flavor, but I go out of my way to have it. Both the s’mores and coffee were excellent. Cookie dough was underwhelming.”
H2
“Actual mix good milkshake: Harlem Shake, Julia jeans and Morgensterns”
H2
“Morgensterns. Buying the pint makes the price more palatable.”
H2
“I just want Morgensterns icecream back…”
H2
“I fell in love with their burnt honey vanilla. I loved seeing how they differentiate flavors too. I didn’t like everything I tried, but ultimately it’s ice cream- I enjoyed that I could make such fun choices.”
H2
“Morgenstern's is one of my favorite Philadelphia style ice creams in NYC.”
H2
“My preference is the durian banana.”
H2
“Ice cream at morgensterns (for more simple, "sophisticated" flavored)”
H2
“Ice cream at morgensterns (for more simple, "sophisticated" flavored)”
H2
“I had their pineapple salted egg and it was fantastic”
H2
“I cannot recommend it highly enough. Made with fresh mint.”
H2
“I chose a Madagascar Vanilla cone, I usually get other flavors but Vanilla felt right for today and it slaps. They also have Vegan options which are really good too.”
H2
“Morgernsterns is technical perfection on texture. Very few spots in nyc that execute at that technical level”
H2
“That rocky road got me through more than a few rocky roads in my life”
H2
“It’s expensive but it’s pretty fucking good imo”
H2
“I always loved their vanillas, usually with some Luxardo maraschino cherries.”
H2
“My exact feelings when I got two flavors for $11 and both lowkey sucked. If I'd gotten samples of either I wouldn't have gotten them, so I guess it's a smart tactic on their end.”
H2
“I had a caramel and i fucking hated it. It was like butter mixed with water. I will never go to try any other flavors. too expensive and it was such a disappointment :(”
H2
“definitely overrated”
H2
“Caffe Panna / Morgansterns for ice cream”
H2
“Thats my favorite flavor too 😓”
H2
“their raspberry black sesame ice cream is super good.”
H2
“their Vietnamese coffee is the best coffee ice cream I’ve ever had.”
H2
“Morgan sterns durian bananna fantastic”
H2
“I love Morgenstern’s. One of the cinnamon flavors tastes just like if Cinnamon Toast Crunch were an ice cream.”
H2
“Morgenstern’s bananas slaps”
H2
“I still dream of their buttermilk ice cream topped with sesame honeycomb”
H2
“To this day, the durian flavor is the most disgusting thing I’ve ever tasted in my life.”
H2
“Truly any flavor is great but the Hong Kong milk tea is my recent fave”
H2
“I quite like their cookies and cream. It’s my second best behind emack and bolios.”
H2
“Nothing special about Morgensterns, IMO. Overrated ice cream with attitude. They don’t even do basic vanilla well.”
H2
“Guava hibiscus sorbet from Morgansterns”
H2
“Ice cream - Morgenstern's is great.”
H2
“Morgenstern's makes their own knock off of it called Nick's It”
H2
“Morgernstern’s for ice cream”
H2
“I definitely don’t think they’re overrated, but they are too expensive.”
H2
“Ice Cream: Morgernstern's, Caffe Panna, Davey's”
H2
“Morgensterns for ice cream”
H2