“Ultimately, I think it’s well-meaning, perfectly decent, but far too expensive for what they offer.”
H3
All 280 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Ultimately, I think it’s well-meaning, perfectly decent, but far too expensive for what they offer.”
H3
“It was really tasty, the focaccia was really crunchy, the mortadella was on point, the pistachio cream was out of this world. 10/10”
H3
“the sandwiches were good- the mortadella and pistachio truffle cream one in particular.”
H3
“They can take my money. I’ve tried 3 of their sandwiches—del boss and odd couple from downtown and paradiso from HK—and never felt ripped off.”
H3
“I went in Florence and the sandwich was completely dry, I mean no condiments no olive oil nothing, on bread that was way too crunchy and perhaps stale.”
H3
“All’-antico vinaio (I got a veggie sandwich so my girlfriend could try, good but would get a meat one next time”
H2
“We live near a bakery that makes these amazingly well, and I had plenty in Italy last year, so perhaps my standards were too high. While nice, this was not worth $20 imo. **3/5**”
H2
“their sandwiches are $20+ which is well outside of my normal $15 lunch limit but they are just so good.”
H2
“I had the Broadway sandwich with extra eggplant and it blew my mind. The pistachio cream, the spicy zucchini, the stracciatella were all perfection.”
H2
“La Broadway at All'antico Vinaio - pistachio cream and straciatella on focaccia”
H2
“the La Paradiso sandwich is out of this world”
H2
“Sandwich was very simple with three ingredients but had a ton of flavor. Excellent quick lunch spot.”
H2
“Never found them too expensive for the quality, and the sandwiches are big enough for 2”
H2
“Their warm focaccia bread and pistachio cream is exceptional.”
H2
“One of my favs is to go to All’Antico and get the La Paradiso”
H2
“I LOVE that sandwich. The bread and the pistachio cream are just chef's kiss.”
H2
“Negative, their sandwiches are amazing and nothing in NY even comes close.”
H2
“I got so sick from that sandwich at their 60th St location :(”
H2
“Take your pick from A’llantico Vinaio and spare yourself the wait in Florence :) a uniquely simple sandwich among NYC picks, wonderfully Italian.”
H2
“Thin soft prosciutto, truffle cream and pecorino cream on amazing house made bread. I add basil to the order. Amazing!”
H2
“can't go wrong with any of the sandwiches but I like L’Inferno (Porchetta, nduja cream, grilled vegetables, arugula)”
H2
“Antico de Venoia or whatever has a KILLER mortadella and pistachio cream (works) sandwich”
H2
“All’antico vinaio for Italian sandwiches”
H2
“I'd say it's mostly worth it, provided you order mindfully.”
H2
“Get sandwiches from All’Antico Vinaio”
H2
“If the sandwiches are still good, I'll keep going. So far so good.”
H2
“My sandwich had so much salami on it, I couldn't finish it. The best things they do are definitely the vegetable creams.”
H2
“the sandwiches are so, so good.”
H2
“If ever a sandwich was worth $20, it is this one.”
H2
“Not really a New York exclusive spot, but a great outpost of a famous sandwich chain from Italy. Get any of their sandwiches that include pistachio cream 🤤 Their bread is salty and oily in the best way possible.”
H2
“Sandwiches: my personal favorites are All’Antico Vinaio (West Village) and Le Petit Parisien (East Village)”
H2
“All’Antico Vinaio for Italian samdwhiches”
H2
“I liked it so much the first time I went back three more times, and each time the bread seemed more and more stale, even though it was supposed to be fresh. I want to give it another try because the first time was that magical, but I'm scared.”
H2
“I didn't love the pistachio spread on La Paradiso at All'Antico Vinaio (tasted like peanut butter) but everything else about it was great.”
H2
“Yeah I’m a slut for mortadella and anything pistachio and that specific sandwich is fucking amazing”
H2
“The ones with pistachio cream in them are my favorites”
H2
“That one with mortadella is crack.”
H2
“paradiso from All Antico”
H2
“Also, it’s a travesty what they did to all’antico vinaio when they brought it to the US. It’s so so much better and portions are larger at their shops in Italy.”
H2
“A mild sandwich, full of veggie flavor but still pretty rich thanks to the cream and cheese. I enjoyed it”
H2
“100% tasted fresher in Italy. Found the NYC one to be more salty.”
H2
“I loved the sandwich I had there”
H2
“I also really love all’antico Vinaio for Italian sandwiches!”
H2
“All'Antico Vinaio for sandwiches in WV.”
H2
“That said my absolute favorite sandwich as of late is the paradiso at alla antico viniao. Mortadella , stracciatella and pistachio cream on fresh focaccia. Absolute crack.”
H2
“A few favorites so far: Gramercy Tavern Borgo Gjelina (super cozy and music isn’t too loud if you want to read) All Antico Vinaio- the west village location has great people watching windows”
H2
“It's "just" sandwiches but glorious bread and fillings.”
H2
“You HAVE to try All'Antico Vinaio if you haven't. It's on 8th right below 46th, and one of the best sandwiches you'll eat.”
H2
“all’antico (great focaccia sandwiches)”
H2
“I agree their bread and creams are exceptional.”
H2