“Went the other day and had the H8, leg of lamb, hot peppers, cheese, herb aioli, just the best. I needed to share with the community. The sandwiches are the size of a small dog and it’s just a wonderful New York experience. Go!”
H3
All 265 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Went the other day and had the H8, leg of lamb, hot peppers, cheese, herb aioli, just the best. I needed to share with the community. The sandwiches are the size of a small dog and it’s just a wonderful New York experience. Go!”
H3
“More often, it’s either too dry, the lettuce is warm and wilted, or the chicken is burnt (inedibly bitter).”
H3
“They are the Katz deli of Italian delis: bunch of guys behind the counter giving you the best deli food with their heart. And the sandwiches are huge and usually around $16/17.”
H3
“Milano is hit or miss. I love all the cold Italians, the prosciutto with burrata and fig jam is the best thing ever. I was disappointed in the Cubano and the turkey and rb varieties I’ve had.”
H3
“it’s a top tier hangover food because you usually get a ton of lettuce which with it’s slightly bitter flavor and high water content is a tonic for the battered stomach. so east side wins for me”
H3
“I recently got their caesar wrap and was thoroughly disappointed. Croutons were soggy and the chicken was loosely breaded so it honestly was bread wrap, and lettuce amount was very under.”
H3
“I recently got their caesar wrap and was thoroughly disappointed. Croutons were soggy and the chicken was loosely breaded so it honestly was bread wrap, and lettuce amount was very under.”
H3
“They make their own pastrami and it is *very* good. BUT they massively overheat it when you order it on a sandwich, so buy it by weight and make your own sandwiches at home. Their meats in general, even regular smoked turkey, are somehow way better than most other places thought they are the same price and not homemade.”
H3
“Milano markets chicken caesar wrap (needs no introduction) ($14.90)”
H2
“UWS one had too much dressing for my taste, UES one was a bit light on the chicken but I preferred it overall.”
H2
“Chicken caesar wrap with bacon is delicious. This is our second time here.”
H2
“My vote is for Milano Market's Triple S- Breaded chicken or eggplant, mozzarella, marinara, vodka & pesto sauce on hero”
H2
“Had one at Milano Market I thought was good.”
H2
“I tried Milano market it was doing too much for me, large chunks of chicken not chopped nicely.”
H2
“Sometimes they have porchetta, if they have it get it hot with broccoli rabe and provelone on their hero, it’s incredible”
H2
“I feel that they're better with their Italian cold cuts.”
H2
“I was also happy to see Milano, but the Chicken Caesar wrap? Come on!”
H2
“A chicken Caesar wrap is a waste of a Milano Market trip.”
H2
“Milano market has a hot eggplant sandwich and can customize”
H2
“italian delis like Ottomanellis (Bros and & Sons), Faicco's, all'anticos, Milano Market (honestly its exceptional here) carry exceptional pastrami.”
H2
“Sandwiches from Milano’s.”
H2
“Milano. I get the E10 like it was MY JOB.”
H2
“Milano UWS? They’re great. I get the spicy joey usually.”
H2
“just had the prosciutto fig burrata and loved it”
H2
“Milano Market near Columbia is nice. Get a sandwich”
H2
“Milano markets Sinatra”
H2
“Amore at Milano market”
H2
“This is the way. E10 is fire.”
H2
“They were a little lighter-handed this time, and I added bacon, which improved the wrap dramatically.”
H2
“i never thought a chicken caesar would be so good.”
H2
“The prosciutto and burrata with fig jam, I think it's E11 on the menu, is so damn good.”
H2
“it really is the best wrap I’ve ever had.”
H2
“It was good but I waited 40 minutes for something you can get at any deli. Would not recommend”
H2
“Chicken Caesar wrap Milano market”
H2
“Pisillios/ Milano market/ faiccos for Italian subs”
H2
“I always find their chicken cutlet underwhelming”
H2
“Great sandwiches. But it can’t be the best in NYC?”
H2
“Grab a roast beef (actually get the lamb sandwich) at Milano market and go eat it in riverside park for a view of the Hudson”
H2
“Lenwich and Milano Market (as already mentioned in this thread) are great classic Caesar wraps.”
H2
“I think I’m ordering wrong because as far their Italian is considered I’m always underwhelmed by it. The cubano is okay but something feels off, the triple S I always felt was kinda prettier than it tastes”
H2
“Regina's Grocery/Milano Market for Italian Sandwiches delivers. Highly recommend... leaving midtown for Italian.”
H2
“Milano Market (but I prefer it with their chicken cutlet)”
H2
“These wraps are the real deal - I like adding black olives personally!”
H2
“It's just a chicken caesar wrap. It's nothing special and you can get the same thing in many other upscale delis”
H2
“Special mention for the roasted leg of lamb sandwich at Milano market uptown.”
H2
“Friend of mine just has a chicken parm from there yesterday and said it was just OK.”
H2
“Milano market or faiccos for Italian subs”
H2
“It was never great. Solid sure, but I can’t really believe there’s ever a line.”
H2
“I absolutely love the eggplant and eggplant special sandwiches at Milano Market”
H2
“Milano market Caesar salad wrap is trash”
H2