5.2/10Italian
AI-generated summary
Get the nonna maria slice. People say it's the whole reason to go, and that anyone calling Bleecker overrated hasn't had it. Opinions split hard on everything else. Plenty think the regular is average for this city, and it's inconsistent. Great fresh out of the oven, bad if the slice has been sitting.
“I gotta give Bleecker Street credit for their nonna slice which is definitely standout. I like their sauce too and for that reason I often get their "red Sicilian" which some other places call an upside-down slice. Their plain cheese slice is serviceable but tbh it wouldn't be my first choice there”
H3
“Best pizza is Bleecker Street (FIGHT ME IDC)”
H2
“I got to say I really enjoyed the uniqueness of Bleecker St's Nonna Maria”
H2
“I'm going to get torn apart for this but my initial impression of NY pizza was a bit underwhelming. It reminds me of pizza from a (good) late night UK takeaway. Fiancee loved it as she adores a more bready crust.”
H2
“Nonna Maria slice at Bleecker St. Pizza”
H2
“Sorry, but that slice is a war crime.”
H2
“**1 Star:** Good pizza, grab if you walk by.”
H2
“Good pizza, although rated last out.”
H2
“Bleeker st is my fave for a grandma slice.”
H2
“They’re all more than worth the extra distance needed to cover.”
H2
“bleeckers was my fav for pizza”
H2
“Can confirm it's a damn good calzone at that”
H2