in:I had some burgers76 pts
“These onion rings were also the best onion rings I’ve ever had.”
H3
All 382 rated mentions, most helpful first
“These onion rings were also the best onion rings I’ve ever had.”
H3
“I’m sorry, but Gotham Social taste just like any other smash burger spot to me. Tiktokers might glaze it cuz they’re homies with the owner, or want to go with the status quo, but it did not stand out compared to let’s say 7th Street (that at least had a more unique experience due to how they make their onions and sauce).”
H3
“It’s very close between the fried onion burger at Hamburger America and the Gotham Smash. I think I give it to Gotham though because HA doesn’t put any sauces on their burger and I feel like that helps elevate Gothams.”
H3
“Went opening night and thought Gotham was awful. Food was cold and burger lacked flavor. Threw out the chop cheese as it was inedible.”
H3
“Dangerous for my waistline but this place is the truth!!! Everything literally was bomb.”
H3
“Went to the Gotham burger social club grand opening today and wow it was bomb. 🍔🥰🤗”
H3
“their double smash burger was solid. Nice beefy flavor, well seasoned, not overly greasy and topped with tasty pickled jalapeños.”
H3
“Gotham was bad for me last time I tried, entire burger just tasted of dry burnt griddle, zero flavor and texture was mushy.”
H3
“Gotham will also overdo it on the condiments. Mine tasted way too much like mustard, and I had a friend who had hers doused in ketchup.”
H3
“A little overhyped. The patty needed more salt.”
H2
“Finally made it to Gotham burger and I have to say it def lives up to the hype. It was delish , less greasy than 7th street , and perfect.”
H2
“Gotham Burger Social Club makes a way better smash burger, IMO.”
H2
“It was ok for a smash burger I guess but those aren't my kind of burger.”
H2
“Try Hamburger America or Gotham Burger Social Club for better smashburgers.”
H2
“7th st and Gotham are both better IMO”
H2
“I’d do 7th Street burger, or Gotham Social for smash burgers over Shake Shack.”
H2
“Definitely hamburger America for smash, or Gotham social.”
H2
“8.3/10 (far better than I was expecting, quick, their chips are pretty bad though but i'm only rating the burger)”
H2
“Agreed, they’re fantastic. A lot of people dislike their fries but I really love them.”
H2
“Gotham Burger Social Club was pretty good, fries were ok but the burger was solid.”
H2
“Fries and sauce are pretty good, but my burger was burnt to hell. Not a fan of the smash burger from them.”
H2
“7th Street and Gotham Burger for smash patties.”
H2
“Gotham was the most overrated burger I’ve ever had in the city.”
H2
“I recently tried Gotham Burger and 7th street, and I preferred Gotham, what I look forward in a burger is that it isn’t too greasy and balanced out”
H2
“Gotham burger for frickles.”
H2
“The two best I've had in NYC have been Gotham and Harlem Shake.”
H2
“the pickled jalapeño from Gotham is money on the burger”
H2
“Gotham Burger Social Club hits the mark”
H2
“Gotham is better than both”
H2
“Gotham burger social club for the best smashburger”
H2
“go to Gotham Burger Social Club or Minetta Tavern for a second burger experience.”
H2
“Great burgers but I personally prefer their brick and mortar location in LES”
H2
“I was super disappointed when I went to Gotham Burger. The onions were straight up burnt and not at all in a good way.”
H2
“The loaded tots are the star of the show here”
H2
“Best smashburger in NYC IMO.”
H2
“Gonna be honest Gotham is just too much for me. Too salty , too sloppy too everything. I finally had it and had an open mind but after the first bite thought, this would be great if I was hammered.”
H2
“It's my favorite smashburger, and their basic includes jalapeños.”
H2
“Hamburger America is fun, but if you're looking for a smash burger specifically, I think Gotham Burger Social Club is better.”
H2
“The fries are pretty solid”
H2
“Gotham is just a smash burger and I acutally don't understand its outsized popularity given how many good smash burger places there are even in the same neighborhood. I certainly would not wait in the line outside the door”
H2
“Gotham Social Club is best small smash.”
H2
“I think Smacking Burger is better than Gotham, Hamburger America or 7th street burger.”
H2
“go to Gotham Burger Social Club in the LES. They make a much better smashburger.”
H2
“I think the burger at Gotham is better by a pretty decent margin, actually.”
H2
“Best burger everrrrrr. Surprised to see this wasn't already on the list!”
H2
“Today I tried the banana pudding at Gotham Burger Social Club. It's the closest I've had to the banana pudding of my past.”
H2
“Separately the Gotham smash burger pop-up was probably the best burger I’ve had in nyc”
H2
“Go to Gotham burger social club -burgers”
H2
“Impossible burger at 7th Street or Gotham social club are great.”
H2
“easily best smashburger in the city”
H2