Jacob's Pickles — FoodNYC

What Reddit says359

View all

in:My girlfriend found at least 3 different roach bodies in her dish at 888 Hudson Thai uptown and just wanted to warn everyone else as it may signal a deeper issue52 pts
replying to u/Kleos-Nostos: What happened at Jacob’s Pickles? I really despise that place and Maison Pickle.
“You mean besides the rats and how they were storing things in unsanitary conditions? Or like how they would have things like open sewers and like rat feces everywhere and everything was contaminated and the roaches and how the open toilet was spraying into stuff.”
H3
in:Worst dish you’ve had in nyc ?26 pts
“it was just downright awful. Ice cold, soggy chicken that had likely been sitting out for hours. Rock hard biscuit.”
H3
in:Jacobs Pickles UWS11 pts
“They have a new chef who is tinkering with the menu/recipes and for the things I get, I'm not happy with the changes. Portions have gotten smaller but prices have gone up.”
H3
in:Most polarizing restaurant in NYC?10 pts
replying to u/pumper911: Think Jacob’s Pickles. One of my favorites in the city but many people I know hate it
“Truly terrible. Could’ve just been a bad day but he was genuinely pathetically bad”
H3
in:Legit southern restaurants?8 pts
replying to u/CuteWolves: Jacob’s pickles has some thicccc gravy
“Jacob's pickles has one of the softest biscuits in the city, and I love them for that.”
H3
in:I went to a lot of places that are frequently mentioned here, here's which ones were worth it7 pts
“The second time I went which was only a few weeks ago the food was subpar at best”
H3
in:Jacobs Pickles UWS5 pts
“And the food was terrible, bordering on disgusting. The cornbread was a literal brick.”
H3
in:Food UWS?1 pts
replying to u/MaizeNBlueWaffle: > Avoid Jacob's Pickles, it's an Instagram/Tik Tok trap now How so? Their food is good and it's a great value. It does get busy, but it's not hard to make a reservation for
“Perhaps my own perception, but quality just feels like it's degraded from "this is excellent, good value, and also a novelty" to "this is a good value novelty."”
H3
in:Most polarizing restaurant in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/pumper911: Think Jacob’s Pickles. One of my favorites in the city but many people I know hate it
“The food is pretty great and the portions are absurd”
H3
in:My girlfriend found at least 3 different roach bodies in her dish at 888 Hudson Thai uptown and just wanted to warn everyone else as it may signal a deeper issue1 pts
replying to u/bigben42: I fucking hate that place. One of the worst dining experiences I’ve ever had anywhere. Just thinking about it fills me with rage. Disgusting, foul shitty shithole that I cannot FATHOM why it was so popular
“By 2023 it was pretty mediocre, if it was ever good and not just the sheen of a shiny new concept.”
H3
in:What are some restaurants that definitely *don't* skimp on the portion sizes?121 pts
replying to u/bikeskata: Maison Pickle on the UWS? I'm a bigger dude, and when I eat brunch there, I'm full for the rest of the day.
“also jacobs pickles! the portion sizes are HUGE”
H2
in:I went to a lot of places that are frequently mentioned here, here's which ones were worth it90 pts
“It’s like… basic ass brunch and comfort food. A decent place to bring your unadventurous eater parents if you live nearby”
H2

See all 359 mentions

Jacob's PicklesCHAIN

What Reddit says359