“Some of them are just average, but the white cream varieties are elite. The fluffiness and perfect sweetness level does it for me.”
H3
6.6/10
AI-generated summary
Get the or the . People call them simple, cheap and close to perfect. It's cash only and the line builds after 7am, so go early. The running argument is Moe's Doughs three blocks away, which some people say beats Peter Pan on every .
“Some of them are just average, but the white cream varieties are elite. The fluffiness and perfect sweetness level does it for me.”
H3
“all the yeast donuts here (dough, fan fan, peter pan, moe's, donut pub, etc etc) are generic basic dense doughs, nothing like the airy soft yeast donuts you get from LA/west coast.”
H3
“it’s nice! the honey dip was softer than my pillow and the sour cream donut was incredible. cash only, decent price, straight to the point, 8.”
H2
“5-6/10, we tried 2 different donuts and the fritter, doesn’t compare to Moe’s doughs at all, and we were convinced the fritter was not fresh”
H2
“Peter Pan for me but that is because I prefer cake style donuts vs yeast style ones and they IMHO do them best.”
H2
“Got a donut at Peter Pan instead. No complaints.”
H2
“In sum: I greatly prefer the Peter Pan donut, but if you like your frostings sweeter, I could see a case for Moe's.”
H2
“I expected more from a donut that came on a tray right out of the kitchen, but it definitly tasted hours old.”
H2
“Sour Cream Donut at Peter Pan. Simple, cheap, perfect”
H2
“when you go to Peter Pan and love it (my favorite there is the French Crueller)”
H2
“Do not sleep on Peter Pan’s sour cream donut. Simple, elegant, delicious”
H2
“Or even better, go to Peter Pan Donuts in Greenpoint.”
H2