“Too much whipped cream, too sweet. Not worth the calories or ridiculous price at all. I don't get the hype either. Very one-note.”
H3
All 559 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Too much whipped cream, too sweet. Not worth the calories or ridiculous price at all. I don't get the hype either. Very one-note.”
H3
“In my opinion Magnolia Bakery isn't that great. Super sweet and too much cream. Sometimes the cake slices can even taste dry.”
H3
“I just went yesterday for the first time and I got a slice of vanilla cake and it was inedible. Driest cake I’ve ever had in my entire life. I did however get the banana pudding for a friend and it was pretty good.”
H3
“If they’re only selling the prepackaged stuff (like what the serve on United), it’s horrible. Way too sweet, no texture. Completely ruined.”
H3
“Magnolia fell well short of expectations. It simply tasted of sugar rather than any kind of banana pudding flavor, if that makes sense”
H3
“Magnolia bakery banana pudding”
H2
“classic banana pudding, no notes 😭”
H2
“Banna Pudding from Magnolia Bakery 100/10”
H2
“Banana Pudding is the only consistent and solid thing from them. I repeat it once in a while and think it's worth it to call it a thing.”
H2
“We thought both flavours were incredible and deleted them so fast. Super airy and creamy yet packed such a deep level of flavour.”
H2
“I went there for the Banana Pudding, but I tried some Cheesecakes too and everything tasted so good.”
H2
“Overrated bakery but their banana pudding is solid”
H2
“I’m a hard critic in banana pudding, but it was pretty great. The monster cookie bar was SO good, I’d go back to try their other menu items.”
H2
“Waited in a long line for a banana pudding, which I think is overhyped.”
H2
“Magnolia nanner puddin mmm”
H2
“The get at Magnolia is actually the banana pudding.”
H2
“Banana pudding from magnolia bakery”
H2
“It you do go to Magnolia's, you must try the banana pudding.”
H2
“Their banana pudding is pretty good.”
H2
“Feels like an obvious answer but definitely think Magnolia is too sweet!”
H2
“I would skip the cupcake at magnolia and get banana pudding.”
H2
“Banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery”
H2
“Basic bitch, but the magnolia banana pudding; had it on a park bench in central park after a great time.”
H2
“Good and rich banana pudding.”
H2
“Get magnolia banana pudding and a levain cookie.”
H2
“That’s gone downhill too. The last one I had was almost all whipped cream and no bananas, wafers and pudding.”
H2
“have you had their banana pudding? every single person (living in NY or not) that I have taken to Magnolia LOVE the banana pudding.”
H2
“I dunno, I get a cream cheese brownie there every Friday on my way home and it's a little bit of heaven. The cupcakes just taste like sugar, though.”
H2
“The first time I had it I was in heaven. So then I went there to try other stuff, very disappointing, but holy hell is that banana pudding just out of this world.”
H2
“I don't think their other items are good. They're too sweet to me. I would just get a small banana pudding from them (just to try since it's hyped up) and that's it.”
H2
“Magnolia’s banana pudding still great though”
H2
“It’s stupidly expensive these days, but it’s so good.”
H2
“Dry and barely a whiff of chocolate flavor.”
H2
“Their cakes are ass.”
H2
“Original it’s hard to turn away from”
H2
“it was delightful. A little too sweet for my taste, but it has a great texture.”
H2
“It’s the quality of employee that’s gone down. The employees there are in charge of evenly scooping the pudding into cups, but they just don’t give a shit.”
H2
“I would fuck up magnolia bakery banana pudding.”
H2
“Also a great time for Magnolia banana pudding”
H2
“I was appalled at how dry and flavorless it was compared to the Essex market bakery’s version.”
H2
“honestly the banana pudding from magnolia is so good that I wouldn’t be upset if someone gifted me that”
H2
“Those cupcakes are nasty sweet, always have been. And these days stale (at least the ones that get delivered for work social events are stale, right when they get put out too)”
H2
“Still better than Magnolia though *shudder*”
H2
“Otherwise huge fan of Davey’s ice cream cake, Veniero’s Oreo cheesecake and rainbow cookies, Little Cupcake Bake Shop, and yes Magnolia’s cupcakes and cake slices (but mostly the Key Lime icebox bar).”
H2
“Magnolia is way overrated.”
H2
“I don't know what happened but I can't even choke down that banana pudding anymore. The cupcakes were always dry and overrated but I swear the pudding used to be good and now it's nasty.”
H2
“Banana Pudding and Hummingbird cupcake, theyre still good regardless of what others say.”
H2
“Magnolia’s Banana Pudding is awful. One of the worst things I’ve eaten in my life.”
H2
“Everything I’ve ever tried from Magnolia is so sweet it makes me teeth hurt”
H2
“Magnolia Bakery makes an amazing Banana Cream Pie”
H2