“This should never even be served. One slice was like charcoal on the bottom (much worse in person) and the other had zero sauce, just a thin dried out wannabe sauce.”
H3
All 611 rated mentions, most helpful first
“This should never even be served. One slice was like charcoal on the bottom (much worse in person) and the other had zero sauce, just a thin dried out wannabe sauce.”
H3
“Prince street was just okay for me. Not an nyc slice (not that they claim to be), sweet sauce, not even a noteworthy thick crust/grandma style slice.”
H3
“I can't personally put Prince Street Pizza up there imo. It's wayyyyyy too inconsistent for me. Sometimes it's way too doughy and bland, other times it's solid but still worse than Village Square.”
H3
“Still a great place though. Probably will have better luck if you order an entire pie.”
H3
“Prince street has gone totally to shit.”
H3
“the quality of prince st has declined a bunch. It was all pepperoni (still great cups) but underbaked crust and bleh sauce.”
H3
“If eating on the go, or traveling home with it before eating, then I think Prince is a better format. John’s truly shines when it’s fresh out of the oven. Whereas the thick boi Prince can stay melty a bit longer.”
H3
“In Feb & March they were the shit, in August the round and squares sucked. Floppy/sloppy, and weird, bland vodka sauce with mid crust, respectively.”
H3
“It’s always cold. I think because the line is always insane they just put it in the oven for 20 seconds and the pizza just doesn’t taste right since it was cooked 45 minutes ago and sitting in a case. That might just be my experience but it has happened 3 times in a row so I just decided I won’t eat there again.”
H3
“Prince street doesn’t give a shit about the franchise clearly because their pizza completely went downhill these last few years and I blame it on who they hired to make the pizzas because you can tell they all don’t want to be there and you can tell by the half cooked soggy pizzas they are giving out.”
H3
“the Prince St - Prince Perfection is a great slice. Bang on crust, sweet sauce, just a bit of grated pecorino. A study in topping minimalism that is perfect.”
H3
“Their slice is my favorite slice in the city and part of the reason I stopped being a vegetarian lol. The crust is so crispy, the pepperoni are thick and spicy.”
H3
“It was very good but not as good as Prince St Pizza. The sauce was relatively bland and the crust lacked a buttery flavor that Prince St has.”
H3
“It’s a thick crusted, cheap tasting sauced square overloaded with oily pepperoni cups. Their regular slices are subpar. The service is horrendously rude.”
H3
“the first bite is deceptive because you aren't sure if you even like it but it hits like crack and before you know it you've finished the whole slice”
H2
“prince st pizza, 5/5 what more could you want. didn’t even care that it was raining. we also had the vodka which was great too.”
H2
“Prince St and Suprema are worth the hype”
H2
“Prince street worth the hype”
H2
“fave slice of the trip”
H2
“Really good square slices and best crispy pepperoni consistently.”
H2
“heard it was mid and wasn’t worth waiting on line”
H2
“Pizza is ehhhh and staff is overly rude and expects like a 40% tip for literally pulling the slice I asked for.”
H2
“The cup-and-char pepperoni were spicy, crisp, and greasy in the best way.”
H2
“Now a decade later essentially they serve slop to people but still have a line. It's still decent but the amount of customers they have, they just can't keep the quality consistent.”
H2
“Still like a square every now and then but prefer a thin New York slice and often a bit too greasy”
H2
“Pepperoni square at Prince St. Pizza”
H2
“Their pizza is good but not exceptional.”
H2
“You saying prince street pizza was good actually devalues any opinion on this list”
H2
“Prince Street Pizza isn’t worth the long ass line”
H2
“John's of Bleecker is also significantly better than Prince st”
H2
“I have never understood why this place is popular. Used to live on the block and never once had decent service. Half the times I went I got a practically room temp slice”
H2
“The Spicy Spring pizza at Prince St.”
H2
“Prince st pizza, criminally undercooked”
H2
“Pizza is good but the guys behind the counter are always such dicks, IME.”
H2
“Not going to lie but I was a big fan of their square slices with pepperoni”
H2
“Johns of Bleeker and Rubirosa are better than Prince St, the hell is this”
H2
“pepperoni square slice”
H2
“their pizza is objectively flames”
H2
“First time I had the pep square it blew my mind”
H2
“Prince st pizza was revolting when I had it, so greasy”
H2
“Prince Street Pizza is not good. Their popular pepperoni pizza is just oily Detroit pizza and their other pies are subpar at best.”
H2
“Skip prince street. Racist and not worth filling up on it.”
H2
“The pepperoni square was good but for me, it's a 5 min wait in line pizza at most.”
H2
“The circle pies are ass. The spicy pepperoni squares are pretty solid but not worth waiting in line for imo.”
H2
“Bleeker Street is easily better than Prince IMO”
H2
“Prince St pizza will do you a decent gf pie!”
H2
“But last 3 times I’ve been they never heat it enough and it’s not as crispy as it used to be. Better options out there”
H2
“They should’ve been removed from the list because the pizza is garbage.”
H2
“Hit up a classic instead. Vodka grandma slices, little pepperoni cups.”
H2
“Prince street pizza pepperoni is good.”
H2