“Delicious. Lived up to the hype. The creamed spinach and French dip were highlights. The ribeye had one of the best crusts on any steak I've had; it was crispy, aromatic, savory, and light.”
H3
All 903 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Delicious. Lived up to the hype. The creamed spinach and French dip were highlights. The ribeye had one of the best crusts on any steak I've had; it was crispy, aromatic, savory, and light.”
H3
“Seemed like boring standard American food - pigs in a blanket, Caesar salad, burgers - pretty well-executed but not unique and way overpriced.”
H3
“IMO, french dip > cheeseburger. The bread is LIGHT and crispy, meat thin and tender, the au jus/ horseradish whip..there's nothing I'd change”
H3
“The burger was absolute perfection, lived up to all of the hype. Quite possibly the best burger I’ve ever had. Super rich and flavorful and filling.”
H3
“The Little Gem Salad and 4 Charles does not look like much but it is terrific. And large.”
H3
“A consistently top restaurant. Got this salad for the first time, surprisingly large and filling (avocado hidden in there).”
H3
“Club A Steakhouse and 4 Charles chars their ribeye, if you like the way Peter Luger chars their ribeye and porterhouse but want it high end lightly charred ribeye with better flavor, Club A and 4 Charles is your place.”
H3
“The service is top-quality, lighting pretty good, noise level moderate, friendly staff. My wife and I enjoy it a lot. Have had dinner there three times this year and every one has been outstanding.”
H3
“They have incredible oysters.”
H3
“They have so many good things so it’s hard to pick for just two people.”
H3
“Sneaky item on the menu that's absolutely insane and looks like it's just instagramable bullshit, the smoked salmon caesar salad. They pile a monstrous amount of parm on top but it's amazing and enough to split as an app for four people.”
H3
“Some niche feedback: the salad is sooo good. It’s simple but incredibly delicious. As is the creamed spinach.”
H3
“I hate when people say this, but it’s overhyped. Going there once is good enough for me.”
H3
“Hey there! You're in for a treat at 4 Charles. My girlfriend and I go there about three times a month, sometimes just us and sometimes with friends.”
H3
“Went a few weeks ago - yep prices are up there but the experience was fantastic. Service is top notch, quality of food is top notch, and surprisingly - their wine list has some very reasonable options. There is a vibe in that tiny little place that you can't replicate at any other (insert steak house name here)”
H3
“So with that said the food is comfort food and sure it tastes good but it’s not markedly different than so many other places doing the same thing now.”
H3
“I’ve never gotten anything not good there though”
H3
“4 Charles was one of the worst service experiences I can remember. I’ve never been shamed for not drinking alcohol but our waiter made us pretty uncomfortable for just ordering soda and water. The food was also a bit of a letdown.”
H3
“The prime rib is my least favorite item to order but anytime I go with people who've never been they want it.”
H3
“For two it’s so hard to decide because there’s so many good dishes but you can always take stuff home.”
H3
“I’m gonna get a lot of hate for this, but 4 Charles is overrated as hell.”
H3
“this salad was the highlight of my meal. It’s dense and fresh and made great leftovers.”
H3
“It is, that burger is still my number 1z steak sandwich was fire as well as the shrimp scampi and the chocolate cake dessert we had. Prime rib I actually thought was only just good. If I ever went back I wouldn’t even order it again.”
H3
“The food was absolutely insane and THAT BURGER. I had sky high expectations (been to Monkey Bar and was let down by the burger) and yet this was even better than I expected.”
H2
“Burger definitely better at 4C. We sat outside in their very nice patio area”
H2
“4 Charles was best burger and best baked potato I have had anywhere.”
H2
“we did the hamburger, French dip, fries and Mac and Cheese and it was delicious”
H2
“Sides very amazing. Can get same burger at au Cheval. French Dip was amazing”
H2
“4 Charles (worth the hype)”
H2
“Best french dip I've had, and equally excellent sides that were still good 2 days later.”
H2
“which is too bad because I went once before and enjoyed it.”
H2
“If you can score a table, a 4 charles visit would be well worth it for their burger too.”
H2
“eat the world’s best cheeseburger”
H2
“4 Charles is the best burger I have ever had.”
H2
“A take away burger is better than no burger. It will still be tasty !!!”
H2
“IMO they have the best cheeseburger I've ever tried”
H2
“Put it this way: it's the best takeaway burger in town.”
H2
“4 Charles (burger / corn / spinach / chocolate pie / french fries / caviar oyster (not on menu))”
H2
“I think the ambiance and exclusivity of 4 Charles can trick people into confirmation bias. If you've had the Au Cheval burger, I don't believe you're missing out on the 4 Charles burger, but the ambiance/service at 4 Charles is phenomenal.”
H2
“It’s an awesome burger, but I actually preferred early on when they didn’t always do the for instagram presentation.”
H2
“Burger is good though the whole place is a bit much if you ask me. The French dip absolutely fucks though.”
H2
“many famous restaurants bordering exclusive clubs more than places to dine (Rao's, Four Charles, Carbone, etc.)”
H2
“The Hogsalt restaurants are some of my favorites, but there’s a ton of overlap in the menus which makes it hard for me to justify the level of effort to get into 4 Charles.”
H2
“I’ve eaten on the patio before - it is very nice for an outdoor space. Not quite the same vibe as inside for dinner, but still good with great service. Worth it to try the burger for sure.”
H2
“4 Charles is impossible res and highly overrated”
H2
“Fries? Perfect. Burger? Perfect. Prime rib? Perfect. It’s basically just good simple food but executed to perfection”
H2
“Not worth it IMO.”
H2
“However, the French dip was the best I've ever had by far.”
H2
“Ps, get the burger too.”
H2
“Steak — 4 Charles, St. Anselm (or Keen’s)”
H2